A Psalm of David

-

Detail from The Garden of Earthly Delights by Heironymous Bosch
 

We in the Ordinariate are blessed with a wealth of great music - hymns, polyphony, chant - from both the pre-Reformation Catholic patrimony and the sacred music that continued to be developed and celebrated in the venerable Anglican patrimony.

The wealth of the Anglican patrimony, its awe inspiring treasure trove of sacred music, is a treasure ready to be shared throughout the entire Catholic Church.

One wonders why, when so many glorious compositions are available, people retain an almost addictive attachment to compositions that are to great works of art as junk food is to cuisine?

A diet of spiritual junk food has a serious effect on the well being of a person. A diet of spiritual junk food robs the soul of "nutrients", the art through which God - the True, the Good and the Beautiful - offers the worshipper who reaches out to God for life, love, hope, mercy and forgiveness. Sure, God can and does reach people through even the blandest or most mundane experiences. The transformation of heart and mind begins where God wants to meet His sons and daughters. He, however, being our loving Father, desires to lead us His children to a lavish banquet. God does not leave us digging around in trash bins for scraps. He offers us a magnificent feast.

The Church, for centuries, produced great art that allowed worshippers to discover the life, love, hope, mercy and forgiveness of God. It is easy to understand why, in a society hostile to religion, so many are depressed and turn to drugs or false religions in an attempt to try and fill the void left by the loss of great art and the loss of encounter with the Artist Who inspired it.

Is it not strange that composers (and artists and architects and...) become Esau, the eldest son of Abraham, who traded his birthright for a mess of pottage? (Genesis 25:29-34)

Artistic Reasons for Not including Pop Music in the Sacred Liturgy

Artistic Reason #1

Sacred music is art. As one well acquainted with the compositions of David Haas, and who with mixed emotions rehearsed and directed his works at parish Masses and for diocesan youth conferences in the early to mid-1990s, his and others' works are a testament to an era of "Me-myself-and-I" religion, compositions characterized by saccharine texts set to syrupy melodies accompanied by weak harmonization. The excessively horizontal devotionalism exhibited in such works traps the person at/in prayer in that closed circle lamented by so many, much like a versus populum altar has the effect of localizing attention in the hear and now almost to the exclusion of the eternal. They are not suitable for inclusion in Catholic liturgical worship. 

Artistic Reason #2

Liturgical music is specific, nuanced, not generic. Most composers of "folk liturgical music" operate more as sloganeers than masters of theology. The slogans leave one wondering to what or to whom a song is addressed, or trap worshippers in a nauseating one-liner that, coughed up again and again, risks becoming vain repetition.

The best liturgical musicians, i.e., composers of sacred music characterized by a perfect synthesis of music and poetry, are those with a precise understanding of orthodox doctrine, language and musical grammar. They are poets of the highest order, whether they are setting existing texts or risking the creation of a new text. Concerning the latter, recall Saint Thomas Aquinas, master theologian and capable musician, who wrote the text and music of Pange Lingua.

The setting of non-biblical texts for the liturgy requires a sensitivity and skill relatively few possess in this day and age. Great hymns produced in an age of great composers dedicated to providing choirs and congregations with art by which all may dispose themselves to God are almost a thing of the past. Few are capable of or inclined to write both beautiful texts and music that uplift the soul to the truth, goodness and beauty of God. That so many substandard works are included in official hymnbooks, a fact that goes unchallenged by priests and bishops, reveals how little people care about offering God fitting worship, and how little people are interested in improving their minds and refining their hearts.

How much money is spent by parishes on baleful resources produced by companies that are profiting off people's desire to pray and to pray well? Sadly, many of the compositions sold by religious publishing companies aren't worth the paper they are printed upon. Being substandard, the materials effect a substandard response. Companies profit; meanwhile, people struggle to pray well.

Artistic Reason #3

Pop music is not sacred music. Yes, popular tunes have been appropriated by composers and transformed into great works. E.g., the L'homme armé tune adapted by Guillaume Dufay. Parody and paraphrase Masses need not be a thing of the distant past. The point is, the melodies (or harmonizations) require a necessary transformation to elevate them and make them suitable for inclusion in the Liturgy.


Artistic Reason #4

Sacred music stretches the imagination toward God. Arguably, much adult contemporary froth feeds complacency. No doubt, some or even many people feel uplifted by such works. The question remains: toward what or toward whom is one uplifted?

Footnote

Art imitating life?

It may be that certain compositions directly represent or embody an artist's autobiography, his or her way of being and doing. The complaint against the content of much pop music, and not just Mr. Haas' music but that of a generation or more of pop composers, is that like so many others, composers of adult contemporary "liturgical music" are:

  • progressives whose progressive music feeds progressive consumers of progressive ideology.

To be clear, herein this blog, 'progressive' is not intended as a compliment.

A surfacy but somewhat useful perspective titled Good Art, Bad People is offered by Charles McGrath at the NYTimes.

Additional Reading

Comments

Post a Comment

Your comments will be appreciated and posted if 1) they are on topic and 2) preserve decorum.

Stand by your word. Do not be anonymous. Use a pseudonym.

Popular posts from this blog

20 Additional Signs You Might Just Be In A(n) Heterodox Parish

-
Image
AI generated image. Prompt: Female minister dancing on altar with incense. The Sign of Peace becomes the Dance of Peace. The tabernacle is not anywhere to be seen. There's no business like show business like no business I know. Everything about it is appealing, everything the pastor will allow. Nowhere could you get that happy feeling when you are stealing that extra bow. Blessings of couples in irregular unions doesn't even come close to describing the oddities going on. The altar doubles as a billiard table that is used during meetings of the Knights of Columbus . Unsanctioned modifications to the Mass include they/them pronouns for God and the saints. The statues of Mary and Joseph have been replaced with Murray and Joseph. Traditional liturgical colors have been replaced with an alphabet soup of washed-out tints carefully selected by the Parish Equity, Diversity and Inclusivity Council. The favoured incense is Social Justice Blend... for "High" Mass. Votive and al
Read more

You Know You're In A Progressive Catholic Parish When... .

-
Image
... you rarely (if ever) hear the following phrases. "Party like it's A.D. 1570!" "We should sing more plainchant at this parish." "I'd like to thank the choir for their sublime rendition of the Mass For Five Voices by William Byrd." "I just love the way the four torchbearers process in with such dignity." "People treat the Host like a snack. I think it's time we went back to communion on the tongue." "My entire family goes to Confession every week." "We need a central Tabernacle on the altar." "The altar servers' lace cottas are so beautiful." "I just love Father Steve's sermons about the Real Presence and living a Eucharistic life." "People are leaving in droves for Saint Pius X Parish and the reverent Mass there. Do you think we're doing something wrong here at Harvey Milk Parish?" "I'm thrilled that the design for the new church includes a choir loft.
Read more

A Meditation: Virtue Versus Hollywood Values

-
Image
Napa Institute Procession, Oct. 10, 2023 | Zach Fiedler According to Catholic Church teachings, virtue is defined as: A stable disposition of the intellect and will that governs our actions, orders our passions, and guides our conduct in accordance with reason and faith. [1,2] Virtues are habitual and firm dispositions to do good. [3] They are not just random good deeds, but a deep-rooted goodness that becomes an integral part of a person's character. [3] Virtues enable us to freely choose the right course of action and have a tendency towards what is good. [3] There are human virtues, such as the four cardinal virtues of prudence, justice, fortitude, and temperance. [1] These virtues order our lives in society. [6] There are also theological virtues, which raise us to a divine life, such as faith, hope, and charity. [5] The goal of virtuous living is to become like God - to grow in holiness and moral perfection. [5] Virtues are not just acquired through human effort, but also by t
Read more

That 70s Vatican Show

-
Image
Satire may be mad and anarchic, but it presupposes an admitted superiority in certain things over others; it presupposes a standard. -  G.K. Chesterton, Orthodoxy A poke at folk whose actions past and present could invite considerably more. (T)he real disloyalty is not speaking the truth with love. And that word “love” is not some free-floating balloon of goodwill. It’s an empty shell without the truth to fill it. In Brazil in 2013, the Holy Father encouraged young people to “make a mess.” That’s come to pass in ways surely unintended by the pope. But in the end, pastoral leaders are accountable for their words and their actions. Because, as St. Paul said so long ago, “God is not the author of confusion but of peace.” - Charles J. Chaput, O.F.M. Cap., is the Archbishop emeritus of Philadelphia Afflict the comfortable; comfort the afflicted. That 70s Vatican Show , a fashion extravaganza, featured designs promoting a rabid retro vibe. Organizer Fr. James Martin SJ, taking his cue from t
Read more
Every effort is made herein this blog to conform to the teaching of the Church - Quod ubique, quod semper, quod ab omnibus creditum est. Comments are welcome.